What Is a Pilot Run?

A Pilot Run is a small-scale test or trial of a new process, system, or change in a controlled environment before implementing it on a larger scale. It is often used in various improvement methodologies like Lean, Six Sigma, Total Quality Management (TQM), and others to minimize risks, identify potential issues, and fine-tune processes before rolling them out across an entire organization. A pilot run is mainly used to assess the feasibility, functionality, and performance of a new product, process, or system before a full-scale rollout or implementation. It allows organizations to evaluate and refine their plans, identify potential issues, and gather data and feedback in a controlled and limited setting. Pilot project planning is the process of carefully designing, organizing, and preparing for the execution of a small-scale, experimental project or pilot within an organization.

What is a Pilot Product?
What is a Pilot Product?

Why Employ a Pilot Run?

In the ever-evolving landscape of the world economy and business, the introduction of a novel product to the market represents a pivotal moment for any business. The triumph or disappointment associated with a new product launch can often dictate the course of a company’s growth. Nevertheless, transitioning directly from the prototype stage to full-scale production is not the recommended path. An essential intermediary stage exists between prototypes and production, known as the pilot run.

The voyage from conceptualization to a product in the hands of consumers encompasses numerous stages, and New Product Development (NPD) stands as a pivotal segment within this journey. At the culmination of the NPD phase lies a crucial juncture – the pilot run.

  • The Importance of the Pilot Run

In the transition from prototype development to full-scale production, it’s almost certain that various manufacturing challenges will emerge. The processes, equipment, and materials employed in creating prototypes often encounter scalability issues when it comes to mass production. Assuming that all components will seamlessly integrate and function flawlessly during initial mass production is a risky proposition. This is where the significance of a pilot run becomes evident.

  • Validating Feasibility and Functionality

Pilot runs serve as a critical platform for unveiling design deficiencies that might have eluded detection during the prototype phase, as well as for identifying unforeseen challenges in the mass production process. By adopting mass production methods, it becomes easier to pinpoint quality issues, design flaws, and other potential problems before they become pervasive in the production of a large number of units.

Moreover, pilot runs offer a valuable opportunity to assess how a product performs in an environment that closely mimics the market conditions. These tests enable the refinement of the product’s features, functionalities, and overall performance.

  • Optimizing the Production Process

The pilot run serves as a spotlight on any inefficiencies and defects within the production processes. It acts as a mechanism for addressing these issues and bottlenecks, ultimately ensuring smoother operations during mass production.

Since the exact processes, materials, equipment, tools, and labor are employed in the pilot run, it facilitates a comprehensive cost analysis. Understanding yield, resource allocation, and takt time allows for the identification of areas where improvements can be made.

  • Quality Assurance

Pilot products yield valuable insights into defect rates and quality issues that might not have been apparent during the prototype stage. During the pilot project planning and implementing phase, a thorough inspection can be carried out, which is often impractical or difficult to do during mass production. Through these examinations, product design can be verified, and quality concerns can be proactively addressed.

What is Pilot Project Planning?
What is Pilot Project Planning?

How to Execute a Successful Pilot Test?

Executing a successful pilot test requires meticulous planning, coordination, and attention to detail. It’s not a task that can be improvised the day before full-scale production begins. Here’s a guide on how to carry out a successful pilot test.

  1. Cross-Functional Collaboration: To ensure seamlessness, it’s essential to foster collaboration among all teams and departments involved. Procurement, engineering, production, quality, and product management teams must work closely in advance to facilitate a smooth transition. Furthermore, when issues arise, it’s crucial that these teams collaborate efficiently to swiftly resolve them, preventing delays in mass production.
  2. Defining Clear Objectives: Define specific goals and metrics that the pilot run must achieve. These objectives can encompass various aspects, from testing a specific number of units to identifying and addressing production bottlenecks. Additionally, establish clear criteria that determine the success of the pilot product, guiding the decision to proceed with mass production. Consider monitoring and setting metrics for the following:
    • Defect rate
    • Production efficiency
    • Bottlenecks
    • Resource allocation
  3. Optimal Sample Size for the Pilot Run: The number of units involved in the pilot run should strike a balance between providing meaningful statistical insights and being manageable. A pilot run demands a significant allocation of resources and discipline, and wasting these resources due to a lack of issues is undesirable. As a rule of thumb, the pilot run size should typically range from 10% to 20% of the total purchase order (PO) size, depending on the scale of the initial order.
  4. Data Collection and Analysis: Data collection is paramount for informed decision-making. Without collected data, it becomes challenging to assess whether proceeding with mass production is the right course of action. Throughout the pilot run, prioritize data capture to determine its success. Additionally, this data can serve as a valuable resource for understanding trends, patterns, and areas that require improvement.

By adhering to these steps, manufacturers can establish a robust foundation for transitioning into mass production with confidence and efficiency.

In Conclusion

The journey from conceptualization to a product’s successful market debut is indeed an extensive and intricate process, with the pilot project planning phase acting as a critical juncture. Nestled within the framework of this process, the pilot run serves as the vital link that seamlessly connects the NPD efforts with the eventual mass production phase. To draw an analogy for the sports enthusiasts among us, it’s akin to the pre-game warm-up. Just as neglecting a warm-up can lead to injuries or subpar performance, bypassing the pilot run can result in elevated defect rates, production bottlenecks, and other issues that can jeopardize the success of the production run. In essence, the pilot run stands as a strategic approach, offering a systematic means to rigorously test and refine continuous improvement initiatives. Its value lies in empowering organizations to pursue their objectives with a heightened sense of confidence and a greater likelihood of success.

Join the conversation!

Share your thoughts on pilot runs and continuous improvement in the comments below.