What Is an “Is Is Not Analysis”, and How to Conduct One?

The is/is not analysis diagram is a powerful tool that helps teams solve problems by forcing them to think more deeply about what the real problem is, usually using templates. The tool helps the team focus on the important problems and avoid wasting time on unimportant areas. This tool helps focus the team on what is within scope and what isn’t.
This tool can be used when you’re stuck in a problem, not knowing what you want to do or what is most important. This tool can be used to plan a solution and decide what should be included or excluded. This analysis identifies who, where, and when the problem is occurring. This technique is useful for pinpointing a problem and narrowing down the search to find its root cause.

Basic Concepts

The Is/Is not Analysis relies on a simple, table-based approach. You list entities that are relevant to your organization and then give them the corresponding entries into an is or isn’t column. You can start by listing your company in one column and its competitors in the other. This type of analysis allows you to determine how your company can better compete with your competitors by working around them.

This is one of the main reasons why some companies use Is/Is Not Analysis templates. It produces great results. Remember that these tables cover more than just the obvious aspects of your business. Even things like team size and geographic location can be important in determining the accuracy of your current operation.

Your analysis should be divided into several categories. These include the physical properties of your company, its services or products, and process and metric information. The Is/Is Not Analysis can be done in a few different ways, but the basic idea remains the same. Do not be confused by the variations. In many cases, they are simply different names.

Categorizing actions

Is/Is Not Analysis diagram template can be used to determine how certain actions impact the performance of your organization on a smaller and larger scale. You can, for example, list an action like “increase quotas for successful runs by 10 percent” and then list both the positive and the negative effects this will have on the operations of your organization, along with the areas that it won’t actually affect.

If you are familiar enough with your company’s current operations, it is possible to infer the effects of certain actions. This type of analysis will allow you to gain a better understanding of the long-term effects of certain actions and how they may affect your business.

Your operations will be greatly simplified when you organize all your company’s problem statements in a manner that makes it easy to index and search them. It will be easier to understand the impact of certain requirements on your business.

What is an is/is not analysis diagram template?
What is an is/is not analysis diagram template?

What are the Benefits of Using an Is/Is Not Diagram Analysis?

An “is/is not” analysis, also known as an “Is-Is Not” matrix or simply an “Is-Is Not” analysis, is a structured problem-solving template that helps individuals or teams clarify and define the scope of a problem or project. It is a valuable tool for various fields, including business, engineering, quality management, and problem-solving. Here are some of the benefits of using an “Is / Is Not” analysis:

  1. Clarity and Focus: An “Is / Is Not” analysis forces you to clearly define what a problem or project is and what it is not. This helps in avoiding ambiguity and ensures that all team members have a shared understanding of the scope.
  2. Problem Definition: It helps in breaking down complex issues into smaller, manageable components. By listing what the problem “is” and what it “is not,” you can identify specific aspects or characteristics that need attention.
  3. Scope Management: It assists in setting boundaries for a project or problem-solving effort. Defining what the project “is” and “is not” helps prevent scope creep and ensures that resources are allocated appropriately.
  4. Communication: This tool enhances communication within a team or organization. By visualizing what the project encompasses and what it excludes, it becomes easier to convey the project’s objectives and limitations to stakeholders.
  5. Problem Solving: It aids in brainstorming and problem-solving by prompting individuals to explore potential causes and solutions based on what the problem “is” and “is not.” This structured approach can lead to more effective problem-solving.
  6. Decision-Making: It assists in making informed decisions by providing a clear picture of the situation. Knowing what is within the scope and what is outside it helps prioritize actions and allocate resources effectively.
  7. Risk Identification: By identifying what the project or problem “is not,” you can also identify potential risks or areas that might be overlooked. This proactive approach allows for risk mitigation strategies to be developed.
  8. Continuous Improvement: “Is / Is Not” analysis can be used as a continuous improvement tool. Over time, you can refine your understanding of what the project “is” and “is not” based on feedback and lessons learned from previous projects.
  9. Documentation: It provides a documented record of the project’s scope and boundaries, which can be valuable for future reference and audits.
  10. Team Alignment: It promotes team alignment and consensus-building. By involving team members in defining what the project “is” and “is not,” you can ensure that everyone is on the same page regarding project goals and limitations.
What is an is/is not diagram analysis template?
What is an is/is not diagram analysis template?

What can you apply the is – is not analysis to?

An “Is/Is Not” analysis diagram can be applied to a wide range of situations and domains where you need to clarify and define the scope, characteristics, and boundaries of a concept, project, problem, or entity. Here are some common areas and contexts where you can apply this analysis:

Business and Strategy: Defining the scope of a new business initiative or identifying what a company’s core competencies are (is) and what they don’t specialize in (is not).

Product Development: Defining the features and functionalities of a product (is) or identifying what features the product should not have (is not).

Quality Management: Assessing the quality of a product or service by specifying what meets quality standards (is) and what falls short (is not).

Project Management: Defining the scope of a project, including what tasks are included (is) and what is outside the project’s scope (is not).

Problem-Solving: Identifying the causes of a problem (is) and ruling out potential causes that are not contributing to the problem (is not).

Requirements Gathering: Gathering and documenting the requirements for a software system or project (is) and specifying what requirements are not necessary (is not).

Marketing and Branding: Defining the target audience and customer segments (is) and specifying who the product or service is not meant for (is not).

Personal Development: Setting personal goals by specifying what you want to achieve (is) and what you don’t want to pursue (is not).

Research and Analysis: Narrowing down research topics by defining what aspects are relevant (is) and what should be excluded (is not).

Risk Assessment: Identifying potential risks to a project or organization (is) and determining what risks are unlikely or irrelevant (is not).

Compliance and Regulations: Ensuring that a business or organization complies with specific regulations (is) and clarifying areas that are not subject to those regulations (is not).

Environmental Impact Assessment: Assessing the environmental impact of a project or activity (is) and specifying environmental factors that are not affected (is not).

Conflict Resolution: Clarifying the issues at the heart of a conflict (is) and identifying irrelevant issues that should not be part of the discussion (is not).

Education and Training: Designing a curriculum by specifying what topics are covered (is) and what topics are not included (is not).

Goal Setting: Defining personal or organizational goals (is) and specifying what is not considered a priority (is not).

The “Is / Is Not” analysis is a versatile template that can be adapted to various contexts to enhance clarity, communication, problem-solving, and decision-making. Its primary purpose is to help stakeholders gain a better understanding of what is in scope and what is not, ultimately leading to more effective and efficient processes and outcomes.

Have you ever applied the Is/Is Not Analysis Diagram?

Tell us about your experience in the comments below!